State of Transportation Management Systems: Trends to track in 2017
What new trends and opportunities will emerge for both shippers and software vendors this year in the transportation management systems (TMS) market? We gathered three of our top supply chain software analysts to see where they think the market is headed.
Transportation in the NewsU.S. West Coast ports warned about “complacency” Logisticians, carriers fret over U.S. economy’s future U.S.-bound shipments trend down in June, reports Panjiva U.S. rail carload and intermodal volumes dip for week ending July 6, says AAR A. Duie Pyle opens up Maine-based integrated logistics center More Transportation News
Transportation Resource5 Levels of Autonomous Dispatch and Routing Download this paper for an overview of Autonomous Dispatch and Routing, and learn how increasing levels of automation support and scale dispatching capabilities and create additional business opportunities.
As the world’s transportation networks and supply chains become increasingly intertwined and complex, the systems that support them are improving and advancing at the same break-neck speed.
Last year, for example, we saw transportation management systems (TMS) make significant strides on the “end-to-end supply chain visibility” front—a Holy Grail that many shippers have been striving for since TMS was first introduced years ago. Software vendors across the board have been integrating more transportation optimization capabilities into their solutions, making it easier for shippers to streamline their supply chains while also making them more cost- and time-efficient.
Over the last couple of years, for example, an increasing number of enterprise resource planning (ERP) vendors have jumped into the transportation game. Led by companies like , this trend opened the doors for more shippers to use TMS as part of their overall enterprise solutions—rather than having to purchase separate software applications from different vendors.
And finally, we saw more attention being paid to transportation execution management as shippers sought out new ways to tender and execute freight loads in the most optimized, efficient manner possible.
Will these TMS trends continue in 2017? And what new trends and opportunities will emerge over the next 12 months? To get some answers, Logistics Management spoke with three of our top supply chain software analysts, asking them what they saw transpire in 2016 and what they see for the year ahead.
Here are the six key trends that they say shippers should be watching:
1.) Software that offers better end-to-end supply chain visibility.
For decades, shippers and vendors have envisioned a time when freight could be tracked on a 24/7/365, real-time basis as it moved around the globe. Whether the shipment was in a truck sitting out in yard, on a container ship on the way to the United States, or loaded up on a truck for a last-mile delivery, shippers would know where the goods are at any given time and be able to share that information with their customers and business partners. According to , research director for , we’re almost there.
“Visibility has exploded over the last 12 months,” says De Muynck, “and we’re talking about real-time visibility, with systems like and providing new levels of visibility.”
He adds that companies like Amazon, with their last-mile delivery accomplishments, are leading the charge when it comes to B2C visibility—a trend that’s also making an impact on B2B commerce. “People are used to going onto Amazon to track shipments,” says De Muynck, “and that capability is now being carried over to B2B transactions.”
2.) Higher TMS adoption among small- to mid-sized companies.
Historically, TMS adoption rates for smaller shippers has hovered in the 10% range, according to De Muynck, while about 25% of medium-sized firms and 50% of large organizations used the application to manage their freight activities.
These adoption rates are now rising thanks to the fact that most TMS is now available in the Cloud and on a subscription-based model. “Recently, we’ve seen about 15% growth in TMS usage within small- to mid-sized businesses market, with some vendors reporting more than 20% growth for that market,” says De Muynck, who attributes these increases to the fact that TMS is now within the grasp of much smaller shippers.
Other key drivers include higher transportation costs—mainly caused by driver shortages—and the ongoing need “to be smarter about how you run your transportation,” says De Muynck. “For their customers, shippers need to be able to provide more visibility tools and more analytical capabilities. These factors are also driving higher TMS adoption.”
3.) The “Uberization of freight” drives shippers to invest in transportation execution management systems.
What happens when you take TMS, put it on steroids, and unleash it on today’s supply chains? You’d likely wind up with a transportation execution management system that’s able to orchestrate multi-party, multi-tier transportation activities across supply chain partners.
These systems also include rating, tendering, and real-time feedback/collaboration functionalities that allow shippers to optimize their transportation activities. “In 2016, the Uberization of freight became a hot topic in the transportation execution space,” says Steve Banker vice president of supply chain management at . “We saw over $1 billion in venture capital being poured into transportation execution solutions for the last mile, and several hundred million dollars into solutions for long-haul freight using the Uber model.”
Such systems allow shippers to tender and execute freight moves using their smartphones, and then track the movement of that freight via a mobile device. “There have been solutions in place for a long time—such as GT Nexus on the ocean transportation side,” says Banker, “but now we’re seeing more activity for transportation execution for multi-carrier and parcel.”
4.) The upper end of ROI is increasing for TMS.
When ARC Advisory Group surveyed shippers six years ago to find out what their typical return on investment was for a TMS investment, it found that the solutions reduced overall freight spend by about 5% to 8%. The same companies told ARC that their freight spend would increase from 5% to 10% or more if they were forced to give up their TMS and go back to more manual processes for planning and execution.
In most cases, Banker says those lower freight costs come as a result of better decision making (gathering data for better procurement engagements), process enforcement (helping to ensure that the best carriers on a lane are selected for specific moves), and optimization of transportation activities.
Fast forward to 2017 and Banker says that TMS has not only maintained its reputation for delivering on ROI expectations, but that those returns inched up a bit over the last six years. Today, Banker says most users experience about 5% to 10% freight cost reductions after implementing TMS, with the higher end of the scale increasing by at least two percentage points.
“The average savings didn’t change much, but the overall ROI did go up to 10%,” says Banker, “with the number of companies reporting that they had freight savings of more than 10% jumping dramatically.”
5.) Cloud comprises a larger and larger portion of the TMS market.
As one of the first supply chain applications to make its way into the Cloud, TMS continues to shift from being an on-premise/installed solution to a web-based platform where shippers, business partners, carriers, third-party logistics (3PL) providers, and even customers can access pertinent information via the web on a 24/7/365 basis in real-time.
“The Cloud just naturally lends itself toward TMS,” says , senior manage of logistics and supply chain at . “After all, most TMS-related data is outside of the four walls of the company anyway, so why constrain your system to just being inside the four walls?”
De Muynck agrees and points to Oracle as a good example of a large ERP provider that has made its solution more accessible and affordable to shippers via the Cloud. “Historically, a company with less than $100 million annual freight under management probably wouldn’t purchase such a solution,” he says, “but thanks to the growth in multi-tenant, Cloud-based solutions, larger ERPs have been able to penetrate the market and serve a larger swath of smaller customers, many of which have just $15 million to $20 million in freight management.”
Expect this momentum to continue through 2017 as more companies adopt Cloud solutions and as more vendors develop new—and hone existing—Cloud-based TMS solutions.
6.) The “indirect” approach to transportation management gains traction.
Transportation management solutions have been around for a while, but the most recent survey of Logistics Management readers shows that just 35% of shippers are using these systems as part of their overall supply chain management strategies.
These adoption rates may seem low for a solution that’s been proven to reduce freight costs in the double digits, in some cases, but there could also be something else at work here. “When we look at adoption, we don’t always factor in the number of shippers who use their 3PL’s technology solutions,” Sethi points out.
By equipping themselves with state-of-the-art supply chain applications—and then offering them out as part of their overall logistics management packages—3PLs take the pressure off the shipper that needs better end-to-end supply chain visibility.
“Especially on the e-commerce fulfillment side, we’re definitely seeing more companies using TMS indirectly through their 3PLs,” says Sethi, who expects this trend to continue during the year ahead. “We’ve been seeing a lot of traction in the e-commerce fulfillment space overall, and with that comes an indirect need for TMS.”
Don’t forget “mobile”
As he looks back on 2016 and makes his predictions for TMS for the coming year, Banker says the push to achieve real-time visibility across the supply chain will continue to drive transportation-related software adoption and usage.
To meet the needs of the market, software vendors will be undoubtedly be sharpening their own pencils and coming up with new ways to help their customers work smarter, better and faster. Mobile applications, for example, will continue to work their way into the TMS equation.
“Leading TMS solutions will be integrating smartphone applications that drivers can use to create ‘breadcrumb visibility’ of where specific trucks are at any given time,” says Banker. “That’s the biggest capability you’re going to see more of from TMS over the next few years.”
About the AuthorBridget McCrea, Editor Bridget McCrea is a Contributing Editor for Logistics Management based in Clearwater, Fla. She has covered the transportation and supply chain space since 1996 and has covered all aspects of the industry for Logistics Management and Supply Chain Management Review. She can be reached at , or on Twitter
Subscribe to Logistics Management Magazine!Subscribe today. It's FREE!
Get timely insider information that you can use to better manage your entire logistics operation.
2019 State of Logistics: Third-party logistics (3PL) providers 2019 State of Logistics: Air cargo View More From this Issue